O’Keefe’s research focuses on the importance of speaking and listening in the classroom. These approaches, she says, have been underserved as we focus excessively on writing (1). Listening, in particular, is “intrapersonal, or ideational, allowing us to communicate with ourselves” (1).
“From K–12, students often reach us in presorted sets. Set A are the bright children, the ones whom we give the most exciting assignments. Set B are the average, who get a mixture of the routine and the novel. For set C, the “at-risks,” all of the challenges belong to the teacher. As we enter the twenty-first century . . . more students, rather than less, are categorized as school failures” (1).
- performance standards – “describe through tasks what students should know and do”
- content standards – “focus on what students should know and be able to do within a subject area” (4)
Citing her own 1995 work, O’Keefe suggests “embedded assessment evaluations that are integral to the whole of instruction. We can visualize these assessments as ongoing feedback” which “support the theory that students learn best when they are guided toward meaningful thinking.” On the downside, they “tend to be more qualitative than quantitative. Narrative comments are perceived as less objective, and thus less valuable than letter grades.” (5-6)
I don’t really see the problem with this, except in terms of practical limitations for data collection purposes. If embedded assessment helps break students of the factory-learning model of focusing only on letter/number grades, then it will be doubly effective.
What is critical thinking?
- Per Barry Beyer (1991), it consists of reasoning, argument recognition, critical judgment, criteria, point of view, dialogue, and dispositions (10)
- Per John McPeck (1981), it is “the skill to engage in an activity with reflective skepticism” (10)
- Per the NCTE, it is “a process which stresses an attitude of suspended judgment, incorporates logical inquiry and problem solving, and leads to an evaluative decision or action” (10)
- O’Keefe herself defines it as “those thought processes that involve more abstract operations” (11), which makes it especially unfortunate that “formal school learning has devalued intuition” (10). “Applying this definition . . . permits the use of metaphorical comparisons, intuition, the connotation, as well as denotation of experience. Students are thus freed to symbolize experience in a variety of ways” (11).
Where do drama and discussion fit in?
“The great advantage of drama, or any role-playing activity, is that it moves the student from an egocentric, or self-centered, position to a sociocentered, or other-centered, one” (13). Citing James Moffet (1968), O’Keefe argues that dramatic play moves the mind out of the concrete, present, self-centered pattern and into an abstract, multi-chronological, empathetic pattern (13).
“If speech activities are carefully structured, if students are aware of the goals, and if the teacher monitors the process as well as the product, talk in the classroom strengthens learning without sacrificing control. Speech activities such as drama and discussion promote the capability for abstract thinking and, if planned with this end in mind, can become increasingly challenging” (14).
Incorporating speech and listening into the curriculum
Suggestions for incorporating speech into the curriculum (18):
- Use speaking and listening within the content area.
- State clear objectives.
- Assign definite time limits and tasks.
- Give prompt, explicit, and constructive evaluation and feedback.
- Integrate speaking and listening with reading and writing.
Four types of listening:
- Informative listening. “The most important skill to learn,” the goal is “to receive the thoughts of the speaker with as little distortion as possible” (20). Students should be encouraged to restate or rephrase ideas to show comprehension (21).
- Critical listening. This is where “we decide whether to accept, reject, or modify the speaker’s ideas” (21). This requires us to sharpen our informative listening skills, and recognize our own biases.
- Empathic listening. Not covered in depth.
- Appreciative listening. Not covered in depth.
O’Keefe, Virginia. Developing Critical Thinking: The Speaking/Listening Connection. Heinemann, 1999.