Carol Weinstein – “Culturally Responsive Classroom Management: Awareness into Action” (2003)

This article argues that well-meaning teachers who insist on conformity to classroom norms may be discriminating against students whose sociocultural background contradicts those norms. To counteract this, we must first bear in mind these three prerequisites (270): 

  1. Recognize that we are all cultural beings, with our own beliefs, biases, and assumptions about human behavior. 
  2. Acknowledge the cultural, racial, ethnic, and class differences that exist among people. 
  3. Understand the ways that schools reflect and perpetuate discriminatory practices of the larger society. 

To this end, the article offers a lot of advice about how to set up a supportive and respectful classroom environment for all students, although its suggestions seem mostly geared toward primary school environments. I like the overall message that, “to avoid the possibility of confusion or misunderstanding (which can then lead to unnecessary disciplinary interventions and antagonism), teachers need to be explicit about their expectations [and] model the behavior we expect” (271). This seems to be a recurring theme across all subject areas of teacher training: students don’t do well with surprises. Expectations should be clear at the outset.

 

Weinstein, Carol, et al. “Culturally Responsive Classroom Management: Awareness into Action.” Theory into Practice, vol. 42, no. 4, 2003, 269–76.

 

 

Emily Style – “Curriculum as Window and Mirror” (1996)

Style advocates for an inclusive “both/and thinking” approach to curriculum (1), where all participants are invited to look into through metaphorical windows for insight into unfamiliar experiences, as well as mirrors which reflect their own experience back to them. This approach recognizes both “the actuality and validity of differences” (3); which is to say that varieties of experience should neither be flattened in a homogenizing “melting pot,” nor subjected to the erasure of “colorblindness.” Style argues that this approach is not revolutionary, but rather “in line with the ancient liberal arts tradition which pursues multiple perspectives” (3), meaning that anyone educated outside this paradigm (particularly those who are only exposed to mirror texts) “are narrowly and provincially educated” (5). 

This text is reflective of my experience as a student of literature, where there prevails an essentially Victorian perspective on canon. Works by non-white authors are peppered into the curriculum on a token (or worse, an elective) basis, and even these are typically limited to major Harlem Renaissance works and a few modern African novels, none of which are introduced with sufficient cultural background to be understood fully by most students. 

As a white man training to be an educator, I must be vigilant about the inherent biases and “detached-knowing” of “the ‘doubting game’ in the Western educational tradition” (3). Our approach to knowledge has long favored an adversarial, devil’s-advocate approach that pits ideas against each other in a “marketplace.” It’s time to try a collaborative, empathetic approach to the pursuit of understanding rather than one modeled on war and capitalistic competition.

 

Style, Emily. “Curriculum as Window and Mirror.” Social Science Record, Fall 1996. The National SEED Project, https://nationalseedproject.org/images/documents/ Curriculum_As_Window_and_ Mirror.pdf. Accessed 3 September 2018.

Richard Ruiz – “The Empowerment of Language-Minority Students” (1990)

Ruiz approaches the education of language-minority students through the radical lens of Paulo Freire, and identifies two particular dichotomies. One dichotomy is that existing between language and voice; just because a student’s language is introduced into the classroom, he argues, that does not mean their voice is being heard. Students often find that the language they’ve spoken all their lives is treated as improper, and must be “unlearned” so the teacher can retrain them in an archaic school version of it. “Language is general, abstract,” while “voice is particular and concrete. Language has a life of its own — it exists even when suppressed; when voice is suppressed, it is not heard — it does not exist” (220). 

The other dichotomy Ruiz identifies is between the “language of possibility” and the “language of resistance” (224). The former is essentially a conformist, melting-pot ideology, in which educators talk about “empowering” children. But “the radical pedagogue who treats empowerment as a gift is not yet radical. Teachers do not empower or disempower anyone. . . . They merely create conditions under which people can empower themselves, or not” (223). Therefore, what is needed is a language of resistance which encourages students to empower themselves by constructing and dismantling accepted narratives. 

I find Ruiz’s arguments compelling and inspiring, and plan to bring them with me into the classroom. I am not interested in teaching students to become well-adjusted to a toxic society that dehumanizes them, though I understand why so many well-meaning educators feel this is the pragmatic approach to teaching.

 

Ruiz, Richard. “The Empowerment of Language-Minority Students. Empowerment Through Multicultural Education, edited by Christine E. Sleeter, SUNY, 1990, 217–27.

Randy Moore – “Science Education and the Urban Achievement Gap” (2002)

Moore argues that we need to “deracialize” the achievement gap in order to make the problem solvable, and stop getting bogged down in two unproductive mindsets: blaming society (i.e. we can’t fix it until society improves) and blaming the victim (i.e. we can’t fix it due to systemic issues with marginalized groups) (35). In order to fix the problem, “we will have to eliminate the various other gaps that coalesce and intensify to create the achievement gap. . . . Specifically, we will have to aggressively address (e.g. with legislation, financial incentives” disparities in resources and teacher quality between urban and suburban schools (37–39). The argument that school funding should be based on per-student need rather than local property taxes is obvious and compelling (38), but the part about ensuring that urban schools have better and more qualified teachers is tricky because it doesn’t explain how (39).

One point that jumped out at me was the example of Japan, where ethnic minorities such as Koreans and Burakumin underperform despite performing on par with other Asian groups in the U.S. This is a pretty clear demonstration that academic success is dependent upon sociocultural position rather than anything inherent to a particular group’s culture. (35)

Moore talks about “cultural disparities” that make it difficult for minority students to adhere to the “normative culture” of science, but no specific examples are given. Are we saying that science teachers need to acknowledge refuted beliefs such as creationism, flat-earth theory, and climate change denial? Or are we talking about a different set of norms altogether? On this point the article is unclear. (36–37)

 

Moore, Randy. “Science Education and the Urban Achievement Gap.” Exploring Urban Literacy and Development Education, edited by Dana Britt Lundell and Jeanne L. Higbee, University of Minnesota, 2002, 33–45.

Jen Holladay – “Multiculturalism in the Modern World” (2013)

This talk dovetails with Cumming-McCann’s work on multicultural education. Holladay discusses the “food and festivals, heroes and holidays, folklore and fables” approach to multiculturalism, which focuses on tokenism and individual contributions. She argues that these activities can be fun, but trivialize important experiences and contribute to fetishization.

Holladay argues that proper multicultural education has three main qualities:

  1. It is rigorous.
  2. It is based around developing pro-social proficiency.
  3. It promotes social justice.

She uses the example of a schoolteacher who taught westward expansion from the perspective of indigenous people, white settlers, and buffalo. This is the sort of creative and highly empathetic approach I’d like to take into my classroom.

Bobbie Harro – “The Cycle of Socialization” (2000)

Image result for cycle of socialization

 

Harro argues that we are all born into a set of “social identities” which are neutral in themselves, but “predispose us to unequal roles in the dynamic system of oppression.” These roles are variously stratified in society, with the highest position reserved for heterosexual white men. The process by which these roles are assigned is pervasive, circular, self-perpetuating, and often invisible. (15)

Members of dominant or agent groups are stratified higher and treated as the cultural norm, while the rest of society is classed into subordinate or target groups (17). The cycle of socialization is a somewhat complicated diagram, but a flattened version of it looks like this:

  • Beginning: born “innocent” into our identities.
  • 1st socialization: socialized by parents, relatives, and teachers
  • Institutional/cultural socialization: socialized by church, school, media, etc.
  • Enforcement: lifelong process where dominant groups are privileged and subordinate groups are sanctioned (16)

Harro’s argument comports with my experience, and as a reader living in 2018 I find it to be a review of information I have already internalized. I do find it interesting that Harro repeatedly makes it a point to say that people born into dominant groups should not feel guilt, and that “if our motivation [to make change] is guilt, we are doomed to fail” (20).

I agree with Harro’s general point that guilt is an unproductive emotion, and we are much more powerful if we can accurately assess inequality without bringing guilt into it. But I also think that guilt is a normal human response that can stir people to action, even if we should move past those knee-jerk feelings at some point. I worry that a lot of people from dominant groups will read Harro’s article and only internalize the affirmation not to feel guilty, without being moved to change the system.

 

Harro, Bobbie. “The Cycle of Socialization.” Readings for Diversity and Social Justice, 3rd ed., edited by Maurianne Adams, et al., Routledge, 2000, 15–21.

Allison Cumming-McCann – “Multicultural Education: Connecting Theory to Practice” (2003)

Cumming-McCann lays out four approaches to multicultural education, listed in order from the most basic to the most transformative:

  • Contributions – Focus on “heroes and holidays.” This is the easiest approach to implement because the curriculum remains largely unchanged with the exception of special days celebrating individual contributions. Reinforces the “bootstrap” philosophy that everyone has an equal opportunity to be great and deserves their lot in life. (10)
  • Additive – Adds content about other cultures to the curriculum without restructuring it. The perspective of the dominant culture maintains prime position, with other perspectives included. (10–11)
  • Transformative – A “complete transformation” of the curriculum to deconstruct, complicate, or (where necessary) remove the traditional narrative. The goal is equal and empathetic inclusion of all perspectives. (11)
  • Decision Making and Social Action – Contains all the elements of the Transformative approach, but requires students to actively make decisions and take action to address inequality and empower non-dominant cultures. (11)

Writing in 2003, Cumming-McCann argues that it is “unrealistic” to expect immediate implementation of the more transformative approaches, and that it would be “more reasonable to see teachers blending their approaches,” with “the contributions approach as a starting place” (12). In my opinion, as someone who was educated in public schools beginning in the late 1980s through the entire 1990s, our society has had ample time to process the Contributions and Additive approaches as a baseline, and it is well past time to move American education into the 21st century.

 

Cumming-McCann, Allison. “Multicultural Education: Connecting Theory to Practice.” Focus on Basics, vol. 6, issue B, 2003, pp. 9–12.

Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie – “The Danger of a Single Story” (2009)

Adichie’s discussion dovetails with Emily Style’s work on “windows” and “mirrors” in curricula, in which a provincial, Eurocentric canon causes all students to lack a multifaceted understanding of reality. She recalls being a child in Nigeria brought up on British literature, and writing her own stories filled with little white children playing in the snow. She was essentially disconnected from her own reality as a source of creativity, because her entire knowledge of literature was derived from a single outsider’s story.

When she emigrated to the U.S., Adichie found that we had also internalized this as the only worthwhile story. In addition, though, they internalized a single story about her as an African person: that she was poor, uneducated, and uncultured. Similarly, Adichie found herself making similar assumptions about Mexicans based on the single story she’d learned about them.

The implications for teachers are obvious. We must be careful about which stories we introduce into the curriculum, to make sure that they are many and varied and true, and that they enable our students to look through windows as well as mirrors. Similarly, we must be careful about which stories we tell ourselves about our students, who they are, and what their experiences may be.

Virginia O’Keefe – Developing Critical Thinking (1999)

O’Keefe’s research focuses on the importance of speaking and listening in the classroom. These approaches, she says, have been underserved as we focus excessively on writing (1). Listening, in particular, is “intrapersonal, or ideational, allowing us to communicate with ourselves” (1).

“From K–12, students often reach us in presorted sets. Set A are the bright children, the ones whom we give the most exciting assignments. Set B are the average, who get a mixture of the routine and the novel. For set C, the “at-risks,” all of the challenges belong to the teacher. As we enter the twenty-first century . . . more students, rather than less, are categorized as school failures” (1).

  • performance standards – “describe through tasks what students should know and do”
  • content standards – “focus on what students should know and be able to do within a subject area” (4)

Citing her own 1995 work, O’Keefe suggests “embedded assessment evaluations that are integral to the whole of instruction. We can visualize these assessments as ongoing feedback” which “support the theory that students learn best when they are guided toward meaningful thinking.” On the downside, they “tend to be more qualitative than quantitative. Narrative comments are perceived as less objective, and thus less valuable than letter grades.” (5-6)

I don’t really see the problem with this, except in terms of practical limitations for data collection purposes. If embedded assessment helps break students of the factory-learning model of focusing only on letter/number grades, then it will be doubly effective.

 

What is critical thinking?

  • Per Barry Beyer (1991), it consists of reasoning, argument recognition, critical judgment, criteria, point of view, dialogue, and dispositions (10)
  • Per John McPeck (1981), it is “the skill to engage in an activity with reflective skepticism” (10)
  • Per the NCTE, it is “a process which stresses an attitude of suspended judgment, incorporates logical inquiry and problem solving, and leads to an evaluative decision or action” (10)
  • O’Keefe herself defines it as “those thought processes that involve more abstract operations” (11), which makes it especially unfortunate that “formal school learning has devalued intuition” (10). “Applying this definition . . . permits the use of metaphorical comparisons, intuition, the connotation, as well as denotation of experience. Students are thus freed to symbolize experience in a variety of ways” (11).

 

Where do drama and discussion fit in?

“The great advantage of drama, or any role-playing activity, is that it moves the student from an egocentric, or self-centered, position to a sociocentered, or other-centered, one” (13). Citing James Moffet (1968), O’Keefe argues that dramatic play moves the mind out of the concrete, present, self-centered pattern and into an abstract, multi-chronological, empathetic pattern (13).

“If speech activities are carefully structured, if students are aware of the goals, and if the teacher monitors the process as well as the product, talk in the classroom strengthens learning without sacrificing control. Speech activities such as drama and discussion promote the capability for abstract thinking and, if planned with this end in mind, can become increasingly challenging” (14).

 

Incorporating speech and listening into the curriculum

Suggestions for incorporating speech into the curriculum (18):

  1. Use speaking and listening within the content area.
  2. State clear objectives.
  3. Assign definite time limits and tasks.
  4. Give prompt, explicit, and constructive evaluation and feedback.
  5. Integrate speaking and listening with reading and writing.

Four types of listening:

  1. Informative listening. “The most important skill to learn,” the goal is “to receive the thoughts of the speaker with as little distortion as possible” (20). Students should be encouraged to restate or rephrase ideas to show comprehension (21).
  2. Critical listening. This is where “we decide whether to accept, reject, or modify the speaker’s ideas” (21). This requires us to sharpen our informative listening skills, and recognize our own biases.
  3. Empathic listening. Not covered in depth.
  4. Appreciative listening. Not covered in depth.

 

O’Keefe, Virginia. Developing Critical Thinking: The Speaking/Listening Connection. Heinemann, 1999.

 

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free